What If There Was No AI?

Shawn Snyder

Shawn Snyder

•

Scroll to read more

We are performing an experiment this week. The goal is to write this week’s Beltway Brief with as little artificial intelligence as possible. Just an old-fashioned Bloomberg Terminal (the original finance AI), MS Office, and a very helpful marketing team.  

Given the premise, we are going to look at the impact that AI is having on the economy and markets and how things may look without the technological innovation.  

In the third quarter of 2026, the U.S economy expanded by an above-trend 3.4% annualized with consumer spending clocking in at 3.8%. That is a material uptick from the 2.2% real gross domestic product (GDP) registered in the second quarter. Business investment expanded at a 12.7% annualized pace, marking three consecutive quarters of robust growth. This category reflects the ongoing massive capital expenditure investment from the artificial intelligence hyperscalers who are expected to spend nearly $1 trillion this year on capital expenditure according to Bloomberg Intelligence.   

Figure 1. Business Investments Contribution to GDP vs. Real GDP 

Sources: Bureau of Economic Analysis, Bloomberg L.P., and Potomac. Data as of 3Q 2026. Note: Non-residential business investment is non-residential fixed investment from BEA’s National Income and Product Accounts and real GDP is quarter-over-quarter percent change at a seasonally adjusted annualized rate.  

Spending on computers and peripheral equipment surged by 66.7% and investment in industrial equipment jumped by 24.7%. Not all of the contribution can be assigned to AI, but fixed investment in computer equipment and intellectual property (software and R&D) accounted for roughly 1.2% percentage points of the 3.4% growth – or about 1/3rd. There is some offset though that should not be ignored, which is that many of the goods being used in the buildout are imported from overseas, which subtracts from GDP.1  

Figure 2. U.S. Imports of AI-Related Capital Goods vs. Non-AI (Billions of $) 

Sources: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, Census Bureau, and Potomac. Data as of September 2026. Note: Index equals monthly imports relative to the 2023 monthly average. Not seasonally adjusted.   

Ultimately, it’s tough to get a true apples-to-apples comparison between the various datasets, but simply looking at the surge in investment in computers and peripheral equipment as a percentage of GDP implies a rapid pickup in spend that is adding support to the U.S. economy. Our Verdict: Growth would probably be about 0.5% lower absent AI given the data we have seen. 

Figure 3. Spending on Computer and Peripheral Equipment (Percentage of GDP)  

Sources: Bureau of Economic Analysis, Bloomberg L.P., and Potomac. Data as of 3Q 2026.  

Would There Be More Jobs?  

This question remains up for debate, and no one has an exact answer, but we can make an educated guess. With the U.S. economy adding an average of 137,000 jobs over the past three months according to the October employment report, job growth is looking somewhat better, and the unemployment rate remains low. However, given the weakness in hiring throughout 2024 and 2025, it would be a natural conclusion that artificial intelligence is causing employers to hire less.  

Interestingly, this pattern follows closely with what happened after the dot-com bubble burst in March 2000. Job growth turned into job losses as the U.S. fell into recession between March and November 2001. It took nearly three years for a sustained pickup in hiring to return.  

The slowdown in hiring this time around is also in response to over hiring and spending during the COVID-recovery, but it is also being affected by a tariff surge, reduced levels of immigration, and an aging workforce. This cycle is also different from the dot-com bubble because the economy is not seeing sustained job losses like it did then. Although comforting to job holders, that may mean that a new period of steady growth may take longer to come to fruition. Less drawdown, less recovery.  

Figure 4. Three-Month Moving Average in Private Employment Growth (Thousands)  
Sources: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Bloomberg L.P., and Potomac. Data as of October 2026.  

This prolonged slowing is probably not entirely attributable to the adoption of AI, but we think it is more than fair to say that AI is reducing employment opportunities on the margin. Early 2026 research from Goldman Sachs supports that as well with the team estimating that AI may have reduced monthly payroll growth by roughly 16,000 jobs in 2025.2  

There is a silver lining though, and that is that surging corporate profits tend to eventually translate into an uptick in hiring with a historic lag of about two quarters. While we don’t know for sure if the early signs of labor market recovery will hold, we do think that 2027 will play a critical role in determining how AI is changing the workforce. If the surging profits of 2026 are not followed by a rise in payrolls in 2027, then it may be easier to point one’s finger directly at AI. For more insights, please see our Profits Without Payrolls article.  

Figure 5. U.S. Corporate Profits vs. Private Sector Employment (YoY%) 
Sources: Bureau of Economic Analysis, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Bloomberg L.P., and Potomac. Data as of 2Q 2026 for profits and October 2026 for employment. Note 1: Corporate profits are from BEA National Income and Product Accounts. Note 2: Shaded regions denote periods of U.S. recession.   

Would We Be Happier Without AI? 

This is clearly subjective. For some, AI will cause displacement and for others it will likely increase productivity and enable them to perform tasks like coding with more ease. We do not have a way of assessing individual happiness, but we do think that the advancement of AI is probably dragging down broad consumer sentiment. 

Using data from the University of Michigan, we find it telling that the percentage of people who fear losing their job over the next five years sits at levels typically associated with U.S. recessions. Interestingly, the only other time that this gauge was so high outside of recession was in fact during the early 2000s jobless recovery. Ironically, fears of job loss did not peak until almost six months to a year after the labor market had started to recover.  

Looking at recent data, the spike in March 2025 did occur during the height of a trade war between the United States and its largest trading partners, which may have influenced sentiment along with long-term inflation expectations. However, the impact of tariffs has somewhat faded in the daily mindset by now, and fear remains elevated. The data also coincide with recent Gallup Poll data showing a near doubling in the percentage of respondents who worried that their job would become obsolete because of technology – rising from 15% in 2021 to 27% in 2026. 3 

Figure 6. U. of Michigan Sentiment: Chance of Losing Job During the Next Five Years 
Sources: University of Michigan, Bloomberg L.P., and Potomac. Data as of October 2026. Note: Shaded regions denote periods of U.S. recession.  

It may be a stretch to say that people would be happier without AI, but probably not misleading to say that it is causing at least some employees to worry about their employment status.  

Has the Stock Market Done Well Because of AI?  

There is no doubt that technology stocks can see extreme bouts of volatility – the recent AI-related sell off serves as an excellent example. But fear of losing one’s job and experiencing market volatility ignores an important fact which is that technology stocks also play a key role through a wealth effect. Given that we are writing this piece while on an AI diet, we are not even going to attempt to quantify it with a precise estimate, but a simple glance at S&P 500 Information Technology stocks since 1990 suggests a material impact. 

Between 1990 and 2025, the sector provided a compounded annual growth rate of 13.6% on price returns alone. Including reinvested dividends would lift this further.  

To put it simply, investing in the S&P 500 Information Technology sector over this period would have doubled one’s money nearly every five years. While not everyone will take part in this wealth creation and the fear or job loss is real and palpable, the market capitalization of the S&P 500 Information Technology sector has climbed from approximately $300 billion to about $21 trillion year-end 2025. That should not be ignored. 

Figure 7. S&P 500 Information Technology Sector Annual Price Returns (%)  
Sources: Standard & Poor’s, Bloomberg L.P., and Potomac. Data as of 2025. Investors cannot invest in an index directly. Past performance does not guarantee future results. 

Bottom Line 

Regardless of how one feels about AI or technology more broadly, it is not going away. In our experiment, we found ourselves constantly wanting to use AI to help answer our questions. It honestly, felt like trying to break a bad habit like drinking too much coffee. 

Using it simply feels natural at this point. We also learned that it is legitimately hard to not use it. Even a regular Google search now provides AI-assisted results. The Bloomberg terminal also now has an AI feature and MS Office has Copilot. It honestly felt everywhere even though we still seem to be in the early stages of its adoption.  

That said, we did feel like we had more control over the final output. We questioned both the data and conclusions less and felt more confident in the results. Our takeaway is that AI is indeed helpful in both our writing and research, but blind trust in its ability is likely a mistake. As of right now, there still does not appear to be a rival to human judgement.  

Yet.  

Disclosures

Potomac Fund Management (“Potomac”) is an SEC‑registered investment adviser located in Bethesda, Maryland. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training, nor is it an endorsement by the SEC. This material is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, tax advice, or a recommendation regarding any specific product, security, strategy, or investment decision. Readers should not assume that any discussion or information applies to their individual circumstances. This communication does not constitute an offer to buy or sell any security or a solicitation to provide personalized investment advice for compensation. Nothing herein should be construed as individualized or tailored advice delivered over the internet. 

Opinions expressed are current as of the date of publication and may change without notice. Information obtained from third‑party sources is believed to be reliable, but Potomac does not guarantee its accuracy or completeness and is not responsible for any third‑party content referenced or linked in this material. 

Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. For additional important disclosures, please visit potomac.com/disclosures. 

PFM-387-20261118

Article

Shawn Snyder

Nov 19, 2026

A video thumbnail graphic set inside a retro-style office with a bright, grid-patterned illuminated ceiling. In the left foreground, Dan Russo wears a grey suit jacket, a striped dress shirt, and a solid navy tie, looking forward with raised eyebrows while gesturing with both hands. Text overlay in the upper center reads "episode 98" in white, "THE MESSAGE FROM THE BOND MARKET" in large bold yellow capital letters, and "WITH DAN RUSSO, CMT®" below in white. On the right, two anthropomorphic bulls wearing white striped dress shirts, patterned ties, and suspenders lean across a cubicle divider, with one extending its hoof toward Dan's side of the partition. A small yellow geometric logo rests in the bottom right corner.

Video

Article

Dan Russo, CMT®

Nov 16, 2026

READY FOR MORE?

Explore our other content, or subscribe to stay up to date with the latest.

Opt in (Subscription types)
Opt in (Subscription types)